Up to 70% off

    10d 11h 10m 47s

    Get it
    UX Audit Checklist: 25+ Points to Check by Hand
    EyeCaptain

    UX Audit Checklist: 25+ Points to Check by Hand

    A UX audit checklist of 25+ points to review on any website before you open an analysis tool: navigation, content, forms, mobile and trust.

    5 min read
    143 views
    UX auditwebsite audit checklistUX checklistwebsite analysis toolUI/UX analysis

    A UX audit checklist is a list of things to check by hand on your key pages before you open any analysis tool: whether visitors can find what they came for, understand the offer, trust you, and finish the form on a phone. Below are 28 points in seven groups, a simple way to record what you find, and how to decide what to fix first. Work through it on your three to five most important pages, on desktop and on a real phone.

    Why check by hand before you run a tool

    Most automated audits look at what a crawler can measure: page speed, broken links, missing alt text, accessibility errors. Those matter, but a page can pass every technical check and still lose visitors because the offer is unclear or the form asks too much. A manual UX audit looks at the page the way a first-time visitor does. Once you have a list of suspected problems, tools and analytics become a way to confirm or reject them instead of a pile of warnings with no priority.

    The cost of skipping this is easy to see in e-commerce. Baymard Institute's average of published studies puts cart abandonment at about 70%, and most of the reasons shoppers give (unexpected costs, forced accounts, a long checkout, lack of trust) are visible on the page to anyone who looks.

    Before you start: pick pages and goals

    In your analytics, list the top landing pages by sessions and note the exit rate and conversion rate of each. Then write down the critical paths: for a store, home to category to product to cart to checkout; for SaaS, landing page to features to pricing to sign-up. Treat pages differently by role. A high exit rate on a blog post can be normal; the same rate on a product page is a problem. Set one measurable goal per page, such as a lower cart abandonment rate or a higher demo request rate, so every finding can be tied to a number.

    The Complete UX Audit Checklist: 25+ Critical Points to Check Before Using Any Website Analysis Tool infographic showing UX…EyeCaptain

    The UX audit checklist: 28 points

    Navigation and information architecture

    1. Can a new visitor reach your top three products or services from the home page in two clicks or fewer?
    2. Do menu labels use the words customers use, not internal team names?
    3. Is the current location clear (active menu state, breadcrumbs on deep pages)?
    4. Does site search return the right result for your three most searched terms, including common misspellings?

    Clarity, hierarchy and scannability

    1. Squint test: blur your eyes at the first screen. Is the main call to action one of the two or three things that stand out?
    2. Is there one primary action per page, with secondary actions visibly quieter?
    3. Do headings and short paragraphs let a scanner get the point without reading every line?
    4. Does body text and button text meet the WCAG contrast minimum of 4.5:1 for normal text?

    Value proposition and content

    1. Five-second test: after five seconds on the page, can someone say what you offer and who it is for? A five-second test on your hero headline is the quickest way to check.
    2. Does the headline state a concrete outcome rather than a slogan?
    3. Are price, delivery or plan limits stated where the decision is made, not hidden on another page?
    4. Does the page answer the top objections (cost, time, risk, effort) before the call to action?

    Forms and friction

    1. Count the fields. Can any be removed, merged or filled automatically?
    2. Are labels visible above fields rather than placeholder text that disappears on typing?
    3. Submit the form with wrong data. Do errors appear next to the field and say how to fix it, not just "Invalid input"? Our guide to form labels and error messages has examples.
    4. Is account creation optional before purchase or sign-up?
    5. For checkouts: are all costs visible before the payment step? Baymard's checkout research estimates that the average large e-commerce site can gain a 35% increase in conversion rate through better checkout design.

    Mobile usability

    1. Complete your main task on a real phone with one thumb. Where did you hesitate or mis-tap?
    2. Are tap targets large enough? Apple's Human Interface Guidelines recommend at least 44 by 44 points.
    3. Is the main call to action reachable without long scrolling, or does a sticky version appear once it scrolls away? See thumb zone design for placement.
    4. Do form fields open the right keyboard (email, number, phone)?

    Perceived performance

    1. Does meaningful content appear in the first screen quickly, or is there a blank page or spinner?
    2. Does anything move as the page loads (late banners, images without set dimensions, cookie bars that push content)?
    3. Do buttons respond immediately when tapped, with a visible pressed or loading state?

    Trust and reassurance

    1. Are reviews or testimonials specific (name, context, result) rather than generic praise?
    2. Are returns, guarantees or cancellation terms stated near the call to action in one sentence?
    3. Is there a visible way to contact a person (chat, phone, email)?
    4. Do payment and security cues appear next to the payment fields, not only in the footer?
    The Complete UX Audit Checklist: 25+ Critical Points to Check Before Using Any Website Analysis Tool infographic showing UX…EyeCaptain

    How to record and prioritize what you find

    Use a spreadsheet with four columns:

    EyeCaptainEyeCaptain
    88%
    Conversions Booster

    UX bugs are silently killing your revenue

    88% of users never come back after a bad experience. Our AI detects CTA hierarchy issues, mobile gaps, and cognitive overload patterns.

    CTA hierarchy broken

    1. Page URL: where the issue is.
    2. Issue: what you observed, in one sentence.
    3. Severity: critical, high, medium or low, based on how many visitors it affects and how close it is to the conversion.
    4. Hypothesis: why it hurts the goal and what change you expect to help.

    The hypothesis column is what makes the audit useful. "Button is too small" is an observation. "The main button is below the fold on mobile, so many visitors never see it; a sticky button should raise clicks" is something you can act on and measure. Prioritize by impact on the critical path, not by how easy the fix is: an unclear value proposition matters more than a button in the wrong brand color.

    For a structured version of this method, see our guide to heuristic evaluation, and for a full audit process on software products, how to do a UX audit for SaaS.

    The Complete UX Audit Checklist: 25+ Critical Points to Check Before Using Any Website Analysis Tool infographic showing UX…EyeCaptain

    Where tools fit after the manual pass

    Once you have a list of hypotheses, use tools to test them. Analytics funnels show whether the step you suspect is where people drop. Session recordings and heatmaps show whether visitors behave as you expected. A/B tests or before-and-after comparisons show whether your fix worked. The tool provides the data; your checklist decides what data to look for.

    If you want a second opinion on one page before you start, run a free CRO audit. It reviews clarity, attention, forms and the mobile layout from a URL and gives you a ranked list to compare with your own notes.

    Enjoyed this article?

    One short email a week with practical CRO and UX tips

    No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

    Find what stops your visitors from converting

    EyeCaptain is an AI-powered CRO & UX audit tool that automatically scans your pages, identifies UX issues, and gives you actionable optimization suggestions to increase conversions. Try it for free, no card, no commitment.

    Free Website Audit
    Share this article
    LinkedIn X

    About the author

    Founder of EyeCaptain. Writes about conversion rate optimization, UX analysis and the neuromarketing behind pages that actually sell.

    More articles by Dimitris Andreadakis